Jews Against the Occupation 48 and Wollongong Friends of Palestine plan vigils on Oct. 7 under slogans such as 'Don't let Israel steal the date,' saying the day also marks Israel's first Gaza airstrikes. NSW Premier Chris Minns called the timing heartless and obscene but said the constitution blocks a ban; he urged Labor MPs not to attend. Opposition Leader Kellie Sloane called the vigils sickening and asked organisers to pick any other date. Executive Council of Australian Jewry's Alex Ryvchin said the day belongs to the victims. Organiser Michelle Berkon said denying Palestinians the same right to mourn is what is heartless. A case for "Leave October 7 alone" is that the anniversary of the massacre that killed about 1,200 people is for Jewish and Israeli mourning; staging rival vigils that day is designed to antagonise and should be socially rejected even if it is legal. A case for "Allow vigils on that date" is that Palestinians and their supporters also mark the war's start, protest is protected speech, and no community owns a calendar date — critics can condemn the message without demanding silence. Sources: The Sydney Morning Herald, Oct. 6, 2026, https://www.smh.com.au/politics/nsw/minns-won-t-block-heartless-pro-palestinian-october-7-vigils-20261006-p6137t.html . Checked Oct. 6, 2026.

Image: AI-generated
Anonymous group breakdowns. Small groups are hidden.
Add your perspective to this topic…
The Living Topics
Arguments are recorded on your account. Sign in to add a perspective and reply to others.